BACA COUNTY, Colo. (KDVR) – The remains of a woman found on a Colorado farm have been identified in a cold case spanning 34 years.
The investigation started in June 1988 when a farmer reported to the Baca County Sheriff’s Office that he had found what he believed were human remains on his property southwest of the town of Springfield.
Deputies from the sheriff’s office and the Baca County coroner estimated the remains – now identified as those of Nora Elia Castillo – had been there for one to three years.
After days of searching the area at the time, the sheriff’s office said deputies found nothing to identify the remains or to determine why the person died or how they ended up in the farmer’s field.
Timeline of investigation
Investigators said they took several steps to identify the woman’s remains over the last 34 years.
- Dental impressions were made, and dental records were submitted to the National Crime Information Center
- DNA samples were taken and submitted for analysis
- An anthropological study was completed to try find something to identify the remains
- Facial reconstruction was completed to try to get an idea of what the person may have looked like
Investigators said they had many possible matches to the dental records, but after comparing, they were all excluded.
Case goes cold
The case eventually went cold, and the remains were named “Jane Doe” and later buried. Investigators said they buried copies of important case information with the remains in hopes of someday being able to identify the body.
The sheriff’s office said the Colorado Bureau of Investigation reached out in May 2021 and asked if they could submit the evidence from the 1988 Jane Does case into the national missing and unidentified persons system that was started in 2007.
A few months later, in July, the Baca County Coroner’s Office contracted Solved by DNA, an investigative genetic genealogy company, to try to identify “Jane Doe.”
The DNA records of “Jane Doe” were located, but they were not adequate enough to do a familial study due to what the sheriff’s office said were limitations in technology at the time the remains were located.
On Dec. 13, 2021, the sheriff’s office and coroner’s office had the remains of “Jane Doe” exhumed so they could get new samples to test for DNA.
The DNA samples were sent to the CBI for analysis. After the analysis, the DNA profile was entered into the national missing and unidentified persons system.
DNA match located
In August 2022, the sheriff’s office and coroner’s office were notified of a possible familial DNA match to “Jane Doe.”
Investigators with Solved by DNA said they were able to find a person with DNA markers that indicated they were a family member of “Jane Doe.”
The sheriff’s office said it also contacted several possible family members of the match and helped them get in touch with Solved by DNA.
The possible match was then asked to submit an additional DNA sample to determine if the “Jane Doe” was related to them.
On Sept. 26, 2022, the national missing and unidentified persons system notified the sheriff’s office that the possible family DNA for “Jane Doe” had been located.
On Oct. 6, 2022, Baca County agencies were notified that the DNA from “Jane Doe” was a match to a person who submitted her DNA to the McAllen, Texas, Police Department.
The sample of DNA from the McAllen Police Department had been submitted in 2004 by a person searching for her missing mother, Nora Elia Castillo.
The daughter of Castillo filed a missing person case for her mother in 1996, even though her mother had been missing since 1986 or 1987, the sheriff’s office said.
Castillo’s family was located and notified that she was found in Baca County, Colorado.
“Many thanks go out to all the agencies that cooperated in identifying Nora Elia Castillo! The Baca County Sheriff’s Office, the Baca County Coroner’s Office, Michele Kennedy with Solved by DNA, Colorado Bureau of Investigation, McAllen Texas Police Department, NamUs, and the University of North Texas all worked closely together investigating and solving this portion of the case,” the sheriff’s office shared.
While the remains have been identified, Castillo’s case is still unsolved. The sheriff’s office said it is now being investigated as a potential homicide.
If you have any information about Castillo or this case, please contact the Baca County Sheriff’s Office at 719-523-4511 or the McAllen Texas Police Department at 956-681-2221.
There are hundreds of unsolved homicide cases, long-term missing person cases, and unidentified remains cases in Colorado where at least three years have passed since the crime happened. The Colorado cold case task force created a list of those cases dating back to 1970.
The National Missing and Unidentified Persons System shows there are currently 21,556 open missing person cases in the United States and over 300 in Colorado.